FILM REVIEW: Shutter Island (2010)
Shutter Island (USA, 2010)
Directed by Martin Scorsese
Starring Leonardo DiCaprio, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley, Max von Sydow
It's very common for directors to indulge themselves after winning awards, using the heft of their new-found acclaim to splash out on a pet project. And considering how long Martin Scorsese had to wait for his Oscar, no-one could complain about him letting his hair down and doing something a little less cerebral. While it never reaches the heights of his earlier work, Shutter Island is a fun and engaging thriller which more or less holds together, and which is made with the same affection for its genre as Peter Jackson's remake of King Kong.The comparison with King Kong extends further than just two great directors kicking back a little. Both Jackson's remake and Shutter Island are upmarket re-workings of rich B-movie traditions, namely the monster movie and the asylum-based thriller. Both take films or genres which are well-worn or familiar, and re-imagine their stories as they would have been told had the technology or the money been available the first time around.
The core ideas in Shutter Island are easily recognisable to film fans, and even casual Scorsese-ites will be able to spot the master returning to old themes. The idea of a mental institute in which the lines between patients and doctors are blurred is a big lift from Shock Corridor, or its slightly more upmarket cousin The Ninth Configuration. The idea of foul play involving Nazi or ex-Nazi scientists is taken from The Boys from Brazil, which itself was rather ripe. And the device of an island or isolated location being cut off by the elements is as old as the trees; Stanley Kubrick was pastiching it when he made The Shining.This revamped B-movie aesthetic is reinforced by Shutter Island's pulpy, glossy visuals. The film is often art directed to within an inch of its life, as Scorsese seeks to wring out every inch of suspense and terror from the claustrophobic setting. Like The Killer Inside Me shortly after it, Shutter Island's visuals are rooted in 1950s noir, not just in costumes and lighting decisions but in the measured and deceptive staging of certain sequences. Scorsese utilises every possible camera angle to tell the story, from tough dolly shots when the German soldiers are executed, to tight zooms on the spiral staircase which recall the ending of The Red Shoes.
As if you needed any more convincing that this is not a 'serious' work, you only have to listen to the dialogue in the first 30 minutes. The running of the island is explained in such a way that you know which elements will come into play later on. And there are a number of deliberate continuity errors which are common in low-budget films, such as glasses disappearing and re-appearing. The film is edited by Thelma Schoonmaker, widow of Michael Powell, and both she and Scorsese are too talented to let such things slip by unnoticed.The central idea or twist of Shutter Island is that of people pretending to be other people, and living out their lives as highly complicated fantasies or repetitions of past lives. Again, we are on familiar ground, not just with The Shining but with Roman Polanski's The Tenant. Both of these films succeed by completely disorientating their audiences: the goalposts are constantly shifting and what seemed a watertight explanation ten minutes ago is no longer anything of the sort. On a slightly lesser note, the actual revelation involving Teddy Daniels' name is a clouded reference to Robert De Niro's character in Angel Heart.All that has been said so far makes Shutter Island out to be a failure, a film packed with enough references to satisfy fanboys but nothing for the uninitiated. Considering that so much of the film is well-worn to the point of being ridiculous, and that is knowingly well-worn at that, the film must then succeed or fail on whether or not it is entertaining and thrilling in its own right. And broadly speaking, it's is, albeit not completely.
The most illuminating comparison is with The Ghost Writer, another Polanski film which is also at heart an old-fashioned thriller. Both Polanski and Scorsese are fantastic visual artists, who know how to use colour and music both thematically and symbolically, and who can achieve a real sense of thrill whatever the subject or situation. But The Ghost Writer is the superior film because it is much more certain of its own purpose and identity, not just in terms of its politics but as a piece of genre filmmaking. The Ghost Writer is so constantly aware of what it wants to be, and of the manner in which it wants to achieve that, that even when aspects like the final twist don't quite work, it still feels reasonably sure-footed.Shutter Island, for all its knowing ripeness and unapologetic B-movie trappings, can't quite make up its mind how serious it wants to take itself. For its first half hour, where the dialogue is expository to the point of being parody, you are expecting a kind of knowingly cheesy film in the manner of High Anxiety. But as the various plot twists start to unfold, including some very graphic dream sequences involving murdered children and the Holocaust, we begin to feel like the film is wanting to carry more weight that its setup seems to allow.
To its credit, most of Shutter Island does hold together rather well. The dream sequences involving Teddy Daniels' wife and children are beautifully done; seeing his wife turn slowly to ashes as the house burns is very striking. And taken purely as a thriller, it is an exciting romp with a series of plot points which fit together while throwing us off. The scenes of Leonardo DiCaprio wandering along dark corridors by match-light are like the action sequences in The Time Machine married to the haunted house traditions of The Haunting or Alien.On the other hand, as many reviews have pointed out, the final reveal involving Teddy's true identity is somewhat disappointing. It's not that the twist comes out of nowhere and makes no sense, nor conversely that we could see bits of it coming a mile off. The disappointment comes from the fact that we have to definitively settle for one version of events over another; once we leave the lighthouse, the sense of threat has largely gone. It would have been braver and more effective to have left the audience hanging, to decide for themselves whether Teddy was real or not. There is not the same level of ambiguity as in The Shining, or Inception, or indeed Mulholland Drive. But it would have satisfied both the conventions of the genre and created enough debate for a couple of water-cooler moments.The performances in Shutter Island are as ripe and enjoyable as the material. DiCaprio may have assumed Robert DeNiro's mantle as Scorsese's actor of choice, but his performances have been much more larger-than-life than his predecessor. While his Howard Hughes in The Aviator occasionally drifted into pastiche, here he is in full-on scenery-chewing mode, playing up every emotion and being constantly on edge. Ben Kingsley and Max von Sydow are clearly enjoying themselves, revelling in the chance to play with the material and send up their earlier, 'serious' selves. And Mark Ruffalo is also solid, even if his role does become more of a cipher as things play out.Shutter Island is ultimately a good fun thriller which is a great deal more stimulating than Quentin Tarantino's efforts at B-movie homage. It's not a 'serious' or 'proper' Scorsese work both by design and execution, but it is slightly hamstrung by its occasional desire to take itself a bit too seriously for the circumstances. In all it's an enjoyable, atmospheric work crammed with enough suspense for thriller fans, enough references for film geeks, and just about enough entertainment for the rest of us.
Rating: 3.5/5
Verdict: Cheesy, romping and ultimately good fun
Written by
Daniel Mumby |
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
|
Labels:
Alien,
B-Movie,
Daniel,
Film Reviews,
Inception,
Martin Scorsese,
Michael Powell,
Mulholland Drive,
Roman Polanski,
Shutter Island,
The Ghost Writer,
The Killer Inside Me,
The Red Shoes,
Thriller
|
- (500) Days of Summer
- 3 for the Price of 1
- 3D
- 90 minutes
- A Canterbury Tale
- A Good Year
- A Shot in the Dark
- A Single Man
- Abel Ferrara
- About me
- About Schmidt
- Acoustic
- Action-Adventure
- Adaptation
- Agnieszka Holland
- Airplane
- Alan J. Pakula
- Alan Parker
- Alan Watts
- Album Review
- Alejandro Amenabar
- Alexander Payne
- Alfred Hitchcock
- Alice in Wonderland
- Alien
- Alien 3
- Alien Resurrection
- Aliens
- All The President's Men
- Alnwick Academy of Dance
- Alnwick Playhouse
- Alnwick Theatre Club
- Amazing Journey: The Story of The Who
- An Education
- Andrew Brett Hayes
- Andrew Stanton
- Angel Heart
- Animation
- Anime
- Anton Corbijn
- Apocalypse Now
- Apollo 13
- Art Films
- Asif Kapadia
- Avatar
- B-Movie
- Back to the Future
- Bad Lieutenant
- Barry Lyndon
- Basic Instinct
- Batman
- Batman and Robin
- Batman Begins
- Batman Forever
- Batman Returns
- Battenberg
- Battle of Britain
- Battleship Potemkin
- Be Kind Rewind
- Belleville Rendezvous
- Ben Wheatley
- Bernard Rose
- Big Trouble in Little China
- Biopic
- Black Comedy
- Black Narcissus
- Black Swan
- Blade Runner
- Blake Edwards
- Blockbuster
- Boozer
- Breaking Point
- Brian De Palma
- Brian Henson
- Britannia Hospital
- British New Wave
- Bryan Singer
- Burke and Hare
- Byron Haskin
- Caper Film
- Capricorn One
- Captain Moonlight
- Carol Reed
- Carrie
- Charlie Kaufman
- Childrens
- Chinatown
- Chris Morris
- Christianity
- Christmas
- Christopher Nolan
- Cinema
- Citizen Kane
- Clio Bernard
- Comedy
- Comic Book
- Coming of Age
- Concert Films
- Cosmo Duff Gordon
- Cronos
- Cult Films
- Damien O'Donnell
- Dances with Wolves
- Daniel
- Danny The Champion of the World
- Darren Aronofsky
- David Fincher
- David Keating
- David Lynch
- David O. Selznick
- David Zucker
- Debra Granik
- Deliverance
- Delta Spirit
- Dirty Pretty Things
- Disney
- Docudrama
- Documentary
- Doug Trumball
- Download
- Dr. Dog
- Dr. Strangelove
- Dr. Strangelove or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
- Drama
- Dreams
- Duncan Jones
- Ealing
- East is East
- Eddie Murphy
- Edgar Wright
- Emeric Pressburger
- Epic
- Eraserhead
- Erotic Thriller
- Escape from New York
- Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
- Fairy Tale
- Fantasy
- Film noir
- Film Reviews
- Films of the Year
- Fire in Babylon
- Flash Gordon
- football
- Found Footage
- Four Lions
- Franc Roddam
- Francis Ford Coppola
- Franklin J. Schaffner
- Fred Schepisi
- French New Wave
- Fritz Lang
- Gavin Millar
- Gene Saks
- George Cukor
- George Lucas
- George Nolfi
- George Pal
- George Roy Hill
- Ghost Story
- Ghosts of Mars
- Giallo
- Gig reviews
- Gilles Paquet-Brenner
- Godspell
- Gojira
- Gone with the Wind
- Gonna Sing Gotta Dance
- Green Zone
- Gridlocked
- Grindhouse
- Guillermo Del Toro
- Guy Hamilton
- Hallowe'en
- Hammer
- Harold Pinter
- Hayao Miyazaki
- Heartless
- Heaven's Gate
- Hector Babenco
- Hiroyuki Morita
- history
- Horror
- Howl's Moving Castle
- I Know Where I'm Going
- If....
- In Bruges
- Inception
- Independent Film
- Indiana Jones
- Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
- Insomnia
- Into The Night
- Ishiro Honda
- James Cameron
- James Dearden
- James Matthewson
- Jane Sanderson
- Jaume Collet-Serra
- Jaws
- Jean-Pierre Jeunet
- Jerry Zucker
- Jesus Christ Superstar
- Jim Abrahams
- Jim Henson
- Jim Loach
- Jim Sharman
- Joel + Ethan Coen
- Joel Schumacher
- John Boorman
- John Carpenter
- John Hillcoat
- John Landis
- John Michael McDonagh
- Jonathan Demme
- Joseph Losey
- Joseph McGrath
- Josie Cerise
- Juan Antonio Bayona
- Julian Schnabel
- Juliette Binoche
- Karel Reisz
- Katell Quillévéré
- Keeper of the Keys
- Kevin Costner
- Kevin Macdonald
- Kick-Ass
- Kill List
- Kim Spence
- Kind Hearts and Coronets
- Kiss of the Spider Woman
- Kitchen Sink
- Krzysztof Kieslowski
- La Haine
- Ladyhawke
- Lasse Halstrom
- Let The Right One In
- Lime Scurvy
- Lindsay Anderson
- Lisa Cholodenko
- Logan's Run
- Lone Scherfig
- Lord of the Flies
- Love Like Poison
- Lynne Ramsay
- Marc Webb
- Martial Arts
- Martin McDonagh
- Martin Scorsese
- Mathieu Kassovitz
- Matthew Vaughn
- Melodrama
- Memento
- Metropolis
- Michael Anderson
- Michael Cimino
- Michael Crichton
- Michael Frayn
- Michael Powell
- Michael Winterbottom
- Michel Gondry
- Michelangelo Antonioni
- Mike Hodges
- Monster Movie
- Monty Python
- Monty Python and the Holy Grail
- Morgan Spurlock
- mp3
- Mr. Nice
- Mulholland Drive
- Mumbling On
- Mumby at the Movies
- Mumbys
- Murray Lerner
- Muse
- Music
- Musical
- Nacho Vigalondo
- Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
- Neil Simon
- Neo-noir
- New Blog
- New Hollywood
- Nick Cave
- Nicolas Roeg
- No Country for Old Men
- Noah Baumbach
- Noises Off
- Nominations
- Northumberland Gazette
- Nouvelle Vague
- O Lucky Man
- Of Time and the City
- Old Crow Medicine Show
- Oranges and Sunshine
- Orson Welles
- Out of Africa
- Out of Place
- Pantomime
- Paul Crowder
- Paul Greengrass
- Paul Verhoeven
- Pedro Almodovar
- Peeping Tom
- Penny Brown
- Period Drama
- Peter Brook
- Peter Brown
- Peter Hyams
- Peter Jackson
- Peter Sellers
- Peter Weir
- Philip K. Dick
- Philip Ridley
- Piracy
- Pixar
- Plenty
- poetry
- politics
- pope
- Porco Rosso
- Prince of Darkness
- Princess Mononoke
- Prison Drama
- Propaganda
- Quadrophenia
- Queen
- Radio
- Remi Bezançon
- Repulsion
- Review Revisited
- Rhyming play
- Richard Attenborough
- Richard Donner
- Richard Lester
- Richard O'Brien
- Ridley Scott
- Road Movie
- Roald Dahl
- Robert Hamer
- Robert S. Fiveson
- Robert Wise
- Robin Hardy
- Robin Hood
- Rock Opera
- Roger Corman
- Rogue Trader
- Roman Polanski
- Romance
- Romantic Comedy
- Romantic Drama
- Ron Howard
- Sam Wood
- Sarah's Key
- Saturday Night and Sunday Morning
- Saving Private Ryan
- Schnepps
- Science Fiction
- Scott Hicks
- Scott Pilgrim vs. the World
- Sebastian
- Senna
- Sergei Eisenstein
- Shadowlands
- Shine
- Shock Treatment
- Shutter Island
- Silent Film
- Silent Running
- Singer-Songwriter
- Sir Henry at Rawlinson End
- Slasher
- Sleeper
- Sleeping Beauty
- Source Code
- Spetters
- Spike Jonze
- Spirited Away
- Sports Films
- Stanley Kubrick
- Star Wars
- Stephen Frears
- Stephen Hopkins
- Stephen King
- Stephen Schwartz
- Stevan Riley
- Steve Roberts
- Steven Spielberg
- Stop Making Sense
- Studio Ghibli
- Super Size Me
- Surrealism
- Swords-and-Sandals
- Sylvain Chomet
- Talking Heads
- Terence Davies
- Terry Gilliam
- Terry Jones
- That Kefalonia Moment
- The Adjustment Bureau
- The Adventures of Tintin - The Secret of the Unicorn
- The American
- The Arbor
- The Bed-Sitting Room
- The Boys from Brazil
- The Cat Returns
- The Clonus Horror
- The Dark Knight
- The Deep Blue Sea
- The Deer Hunter
- The Diving Bell and the Butterfly
- The Eagle
- The Elephant Man
- The Fellowship of the Ring
- The First Day of the Rest of Your Life
- The Fog
- The Ghost Writer
- The Go-Between
- The Goon Show
- The Guard
- The Haunting
- The Hermit's Tale
- The Illusionist
- The Kids Are All Right
- The Killer Inside Me
- The King's Speech
- The Lady Vanishes
- The Life and Death of Peter Sellers
- The Lord of the Rings
- The Lovely Bones
- The Magic Christian
- The Man Who Fell to Earth
- The Man Who Knew Too Much
- The Muppet Christmas Carol
- The Ninth Gate
- The Odd Couple
- The Omen
- The Orphanage
- The Others
- The Paradine Case
- The Party
- The Passenger
- The Pink Panther
- The Prestige
- The Proposition
- The Red Shoes
- The Rest Of Your Life
- The Return of the King
- The Road
- The Rocky Horror Picture Show
- The Secret Garden
- The Skin I Live In
- The Social Network
- The Squid and the Whale
- The Sting
- The Thing
- The Third Man
- The Two Towers
- The Usual Suspects
- The Verve
- The War of the Worlds
- The Who
- The Wicker Man
- Theatre
- Theatre Reviews
- They Live
- Three Colours - Blue
- Three Colours - White
- Thriller
- Tideland
- Tim Burton
- Timecrimes
- Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
- Titanic
- Tom
- Tom Hooper
- Tomas Alfredson
- Total Recall
- Touching the Void
- Trading Places
- Treetop Flyers
- True Grit
- Twelve Monkeys
- Tyneside Cinema
- Unknown
- Victor Fleming
- Wake Wood
- WALL-E
- War Film
- Warkworth Drama Group
- Watchmen
- We Need To Talk About Kevin
- Western
- Westworld
- What's Eating Gilbert Grape?
- WhatCulture
- Wild at Heart
- William Peter Blatty
- Wim Wenders
- Wind in the Willows
- Wings of Desire
- Winter's Bone
- Witness
- Woody Allen
- World Cinema
- Zack Snyder
-
Reflections - It is weird to read my correspondences from the late August/early September period, being the time of transition between my old function in life to my new ...12 years ago
-
MOTHBALLED - While Mix and Match with Mumby continues on Lionheart Radio, this blog will no longer be updated. Thanks for reading :) Daniel12 years ago
-
Let's wrap things up - Dear all, It's been a while since I posted on here. A lot has happened in the last six months which has prevented me from posting new stuff on here. Gradua...14 years ago
-
0 comments:
Post a Comment